
In Peru we confuse indicators with diagnoses. Two examples affect our health policies: anemia and so-called chronic childhood malnutrition. Both deserve priority attention, but their names and numbers can lead to wrong interventions when their multiple causes are not considered.
In Peru we confuse indicators with diagnoses. Two examples affect our health policies: anemia and so-called chronic childhood malnutrition. Both deserve priority attention, but their names and numbers can lead to wrong interventions when their multiple causes are not considered.
Anemia is identified by a hemoglobin concentration below the threshold established for age, sex and certain physiological conditions. Hemoglobin carries oxygen to tissues; Therefore, a significant reduction can harm children’s health and development. However, anemia does not necessarily mean a lack of iron. It may be related to infections, inflammation, vitamin B12 or folate deficiencies, inherited blood diseases, and other disorders. Interpreting the downward correction of hemoglobin concentration in populations living at high altitude requires special caution due to its diagnostic implications.
Iron deficiency is a major cause of anemia and must be treated. But administering iron does not solve all cases. With inflammation, the response to supplementation may be limited: the hormone hepcidin decreases iron absorption and restricts its availability. It is advisable to improve diet, prevent infections, provide safe water and properly evaluate, without confusing hemoglobin levels with etiological diagnoses.
Something similar happens with chronic childhood malnutrition, since its name leads to confusion. The global indicator used is anthropometric, not a diagnosis: growth retardation or ‘stunting’, height for age below the median of the World Health Organization standards by more than two standard deviations. It does not measure how well a child eats nor does it prove, by itself, that he or she is malnourished. And growth reflects accumulated processes. Maternal and infant nutrition matters, as do repeated infections, sanitation, and other factors. Therefore, reducing stunting requires much more than handing out food or supplements. Nor can it be expected that a short campaign will recover the lost stature.
Between 2008 and 2025, childhood stunting rose from 28.5% to 12.1%, while anemia continued to affect more than a third of young children. Confusing anemia with iron deficiency and growth retardation with proven malnutrition can lead to wrong public health responses and leave other causes unaddressed.
*El Comercio opens its pages to the exchange of ideas and reflections. In this plural framework, the Diario does not necessarily agree with the opinions of the columnists who sign them, although it always respects them.














