He United States Senate rejected this Thursday a new bipartisan resolution aimed at restricting President Donald Trump’s authority to order military deployments and carry out war operations against Iran without express authorization from Congress.
With a result of 48 votes in favor and 51 against, the initiative failed for the fifteenth time since the outbreak of hostilities on February 28.
During the vote in the chamber, three Republican senators—Susan Collins, of Maine; Lisa Murkowski, from Alaska; and Rand Paul of Kentucky — joined 45 Democratic lawmakers in supporting the measure.
In the Democratic bloc, only the senator from Pennsylvania, John Fetterman, voted against restricting the military powers of the Executive.
The debate constituted the first legislative effort in either chamber of Congress to limit US operations in Middle East since the legislative elections of November 3, a day in which the Republican Party suffered a severe electoral setback.
Since the beginning of the conflict in February, the only approval recorded in the Capitol occurred on June 23 in the House of Representativeswhere a similar text of fundamentally symbolic scope prospered.
Arguments in the full and constitutional scope of the measure
Before the vote, Democratic Senator from Virginia, Tim Kaine – the main sponsor of the war powers resolutions regarding the iranian conflict—, urged the Republican bench to support the proposal, recalling the political cost that the military escalation represented for the ruling party in the recent polls and describing the war campaign as “illegal and catastrophic.”
The text under consideration ordered the president to “withdraw the United States Armed Forces from hostilities with Iran.”
Had it passed the parliamentary procedure, its practical effect would have been mostly declarative due to the legal dispute surrounding this institutional mechanism.
Historic dispute over the 1973 War Powers Resolution
In accordance with the provisions of the War Powers Resolution of 1973the president is obliged to withdraw US troops from a theater of hostilities “if Congress so orders by a concurrent resolution” that does not require the signature of the Executive.
However, successive administrations, both Democrats and Republicans, have maintained that this procedure violates the separation of powers established in the Constitution.
Consistent with that position, the White House reiterated its objection to the constitutional validity of this type of resolution after the Lower House approve a similar measure during the summer, keeping intact the operational conduct of the military campaign in Iran.















