Thursday, November 19, 2026
    The GeoStrategic Consensus
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Login
    • HOME
    • AMERICAS
      • Argentina
      • Brazil
      • Canada
      • Chile
      • Colombia
      • Costa Rica
      • Cuba
      • Dominican Republic
      • Ecuador
      • El Salvador
      • Greenland
      • Guatemala
      • Honduras
      • Mexico
      • Nicaragua
      • Panama
      • Paraguay
      • Peru
      • United States
      • Uruguay
      • Venezuela
    • ASIA-PACIFIC
      • Australia
      • Brunei Darussalam
      • Cambodia
      • China
      • Federated States of Micronesia
      • Fiji
      • Indonesia
      • Japan
      • Kiribati
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Marshall Islands
      • Mongolia
      • Myanmar
      • Nauru
      • New Zealand
      • North Korea
      • Palau
      • Papua New Guinea
      • Philippines
      • Samoa
      • Singapore
      • Solomon Islands
      • South Korea
      • Taiwan
      • Thailand
      • Timor-Leste
      • Tonga
      • Tuvalu
      • Vanuatu
      • Vietnam
    • CARICOM
      • CARICOM – Non-English
        • Haiti
        • Suriname
      • CARICOM Associates
        • Anguilla
        • Bermuda
        • British-Virgin-Islands
        • Cayman-Islands
        • Curacao
        • Turks-and-Caicos
      • CARICOM English
        • Antigua and Barbuda
        • Barbados
        • Belize
        • Dominica
        • Grenada
        • Guyana
        • Jamaica
        • Montserrat
        • Saint Kitts and Nevis
        • Saint Lucia
        • Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
        • The Bahamas
        • Trinidad and Tobago
    • EURASIA
      • Armenia
      • Azerbaijan
      • Balarus
      • Georgia
      • Kazakhstan
      • Kyrgyzstan
      • Moldova
      • Russia
      • Tajikistan
      • Turkmenistan
      • Ukraine
      • Uzbekistan
    • EUROPE
      • Albania
      • Andorra
      • Austria
      • Bosnia and Herzegovina
      • Bulgaria
      • Croatia
      • Cyprus
      • Czech Republic
      • Denmark
      • Estonia
      • Finland
      • France
      • Germany
      • Greece
      • Holy See
      • Hungary
      • Iceland
      • Ireland
      • Italy
      • Kosovo
      • Latvia
      • Liechtenstein
      • Lithuania
      • Luxembourg
      • Malta
      • Monaco
      • Montenegro
      • Netherlands
      • North Macedonia
      • Norway
      • Poland
      • Portugal
      • Romania
      • San Marino
      • Serbia
      • Slovakia
      • Slovenia
      • Spain
      • Sweden
      • Switzerland
      • United Kingdom
    • MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA
      • Algeria
      • Bahrain
      • Egypt
      • Iran
      • Iraq
      • Israel
      • Jordan
      • Kuwait
      • Lebanon
      • Lybia
      • Morocco
      • Oman
      • Palestinian Territories
      • Qatar
      • Saudi Arabia
      • Syria
      • Tunisia
      • Turkey
      • United Arab Emirates
      • Western Sahara
      • Yemen
    • SOUTH ASIA
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • Bhutan
      • India
      • Maldives
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA
      • Angola
      • Benin
      • Botswana
      • Burkina Faso
      • Burundi
      • Cabo Verde
      • Cameroon
      • Central African Republic
      • Chad
      • Comoros
      • Cote d’Ivoire
      • Democratic Republic of the Congo
      • Djibouti
      • Equatorial Guinea
      • Eritrea
      • Eswatini
      • Ethiopia
      • Gabon
      • Gambia
      • Ghana
      • Guinea
      • Guinea Bissau
      • Kenya
      • Lesotho
      • Liberia
      • Madagascar
      • Malawi
      • Mali
      • Mauritania
      • Mauritius
      • Mozambique
      • Namibia
      • Niger
      • Nigeria
      • Republic of the Congo
      • Rwanda
      • Sao Tome and Principe
      • Senegal
      • Seychelles
      • Sierra Leone
      • Somalia
      • South Africa
      • South Sudan
      • Sudan
      • Tanzania
      • Togo
      • Uganda
      • Zambia
      • Zimbabwe
    • HOME
    • AMERICAS
      • Argentina
      • Brazil
      • Canada
      • Chile
      • Colombia
      • Costa Rica
      • Cuba
      • Dominican Republic
      • Ecuador
      • El Salvador
      • Greenland
      • Guatemala
      • Honduras
      • Mexico
      • Nicaragua
      • Panama
      • Paraguay
      • Peru
      • United States
      • Uruguay
      • Venezuela
    • ASIA-PACIFIC
      • Australia
      • Brunei Darussalam
      • Cambodia
      • China
      • Federated States of Micronesia
      • Fiji
      • Indonesia
      • Japan
      • Kiribati
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Marshall Islands
      • Mongolia
      • Myanmar
      • Nauru
      • New Zealand
      • North Korea
      • Palau
      • Papua New Guinea
      • Philippines
      • Samoa
      • Singapore
      • Solomon Islands
      • South Korea
      • Taiwan
      • Thailand
      • Timor-Leste
      • Tonga
      • Tuvalu
      • Vanuatu
      • Vietnam
    • CARICOM
      • CARICOM – Non-English
        • Haiti
        • Suriname
      • CARICOM Associates
        • Anguilla
        • Bermuda
        • British-Virgin-Islands
        • Cayman-Islands
        • Curacao
        • Turks-and-Caicos
      • CARICOM English
        • Antigua and Barbuda
        • Barbados
        • Belize
        • Dominica
        • Grenada
        • Guyana
        • Jamaica
        • Montserrat
        • Saint Kitts and Nevis
        • Saint Lucia
        • Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
        • The Bahamas
        • Trinidad and Tobago
    • EURASIA
      • Armenia
      • Azerbaijan
      • Balarus
      • Georgia
      • Kazakhstan
      • Kyrgyzstan
      • Moldova
      • Russia
      • Tajikistan
      • Turkmenistan
      • Ukraine
      • Uzbekistan
    • EUROPE
      • Albania
      • Andorra
      • Austria
      • Bosnia and Herzegovina
      • Bulgaria
      • Croatia
      • Cyprus
      • Czech Republic
      • Denmark
      • Estonia
      • Finland
      • France
      • Germany
      • Greece
      • Holy See
      • Hungary
      • Iceland
      • Ireland
      • Italy
      • Kosovo
      • Latvia
      • Liechtenstein
      • Lithuania
      • Luxembourg
      • Malta
      • Monaco
      • Montenegro
      • Netherlands
      • North Macedonia
      • Norway
      • Poland
      • Portugal
      • Romania
      • San Marino
      • Serbia
      • Slovakia
      • Slovenia
      • Spain
      • Sweden
      • Switzerland
      • United Kingdom
    • MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA
      • Algeria
      • Bahrain
      • Egypt
      • Iran
      • Iraq
      • Israel
      • Jordan
      • Kuwait
      • Lebanon
      • Lybia
      • Morocco
      • Oman
      • Palestinian Territories
      • Qatar
      • Saudi Arabia
      • Syria
      • Tunisia
      • Turkey
      • United Arab Emirates
      • Western Sahara
      • Yemen
    • SOUTH ASIA
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • Bhutan
      • India
      • Maldives
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA
      • Angola
      • Benin
      • Botswana
      • Burkina Faso
      • Burundi
      • Cabo Verde
      • Cameroon
      • Central African Republic
      • Chad
      • Comoros
      • Cote d’Ivoire
      • Democratic Republic of the Congo
      • Djibouti
      • Equatorial Guinea
      • Eritrea
      • Eswatini
      • Ethiopia
      • Gabon
      • Gambia
      • Ghana
      • Guinea
      • Guinea Bissau
      • Kenya
      • Lesotho
      • Liberia
      • Madagascar
      • Malawi
      • Mali
      • Mauritania
      • Mauritius
      • Mozambique
      • Namibia
      • Niger
      • Nigeria
      • Republic of the Congo
      • Rwanda
      • Sao Tome and Principe
      • Senegal
      • Seychelles
      • Sierra Leone
      • Somalia
      • South Africa
      • South Sudan
      • Sudan
      • Tanzania
      • Togo
      • Uganda
      • Zambia
      • Zimbabwe
    No Result
    View All Result
    Agentially
    No Result
    View All Result
    Home SOUTH ASIA India

    Proposed Supreme Court visit of parliamentary panel studying simultaneous elections: Why is separation of powers an issue?

    The Analyst by The Analyst
    October 4, 2026
    in India
    Proposed Supreme Court visit of parliamentary panel studying simultaneous elections: Why is separation of powers an issue?


    The proposed visit of the Joint Parliamentary Committee examining the ‘One Nation, One Election’ Bills to the Supreme Court has raised questions about the separation of powers between Parliament and the judiciary.

    READ ALSO

    How MGR and his Tamil Nadu administration acted tough with LTTE 40 years ago

    Maharashtra Cabinet clears university law amendments, textile policy changes and new courts in Palghar

    While parliamentary committees have interacted with sitting Judges in the past, the Opposition has objected to Judges being consulted on the merits or constitutional validity of a Bill that could later come before the Supreme Court.

    What is the JPC examining?

    The Joint Parliamentary Committee is examining the Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill, 2024, and the Union Territories Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2024. The Bills seek to provide a framework for holding elections to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies together. They were introduced in the Lok Sabha in December 2024 and referred to the Joint Committee for detailed examination.

    Why did the committee wanted to meet the Supreme Court judges?

    The committee, headed by BJP MP P.P. Chaudhary, had proposed a visit to the Supreme Court on October 6, 2026. The programme mentioned an informal interaction with the Chief Justice of India and other Judges on simultaneous elections.

    The proposed visit was subsequently put off. Mr. Chaudhary said the dates of committee members did not match, and that he had other commitments. The proposed interaction had already triggered objections from Opposition members.

    What was the Opposition’s objection?

    The Opposition’s objection is not to parliamentary committees visiting the Supreme Court or interacting with Judges. The concern is about what the Judges were expected to discuss — whether sitting Supreme Court Judges should be asked for their views on legislation that Parliament is considering, and which could, after becoming law, be challenged before the Supreme Court.

    Independent Rajya Sabha member Kapil Sibal called the proposed interaction “unconstitutional,” and said Parliament has the power to make laws, while the judiciary has the power to examine their constitutional validity. The argument is straightforward: Parliament debates and passes a law, and if that law is challenged, the courts decide whether it is in accordance with the Constitution. The Opposition, therefore, argued that asking sitting Judges for their views on the proposed law would blur this distinction.

    The committee chairman, however, has said the proposed visit was not intended to seek the Judges’ views on the Bills, and was meant as a study visit.

    What is the principle of separation of powers?

    There is no single provision in the Constitution that rigidly defines separation of powers. Instead, it gives different responsibilities to the three organs of the State — the legislature, the executive and the judiciary. Parliament, the highest legislative body, makes laws. The executive implements and administers those laws. The judiciary interprets the Constitution and laws, and can examine whether laws passed by Parliament are constitutionally valid.

    Several provisions of the Constitution reflect this division. Article 79 establishes Parliament, comprising the President, the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha. Articles 73 and 74 deal with the executive power of the Union and the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister. Article 124 establishes the Supreme Court of India.

    The Constitution also protects the independence of the judiciary. Article 121, for example, does not allow any discussion on the conduct of Supreme Court and High Court Judges in Parliament, except during proceedings for their removal. There are similar safeguards for Judges in State legislatures under Article 211.

    The Constitution also provides for judicial review, meaning courts can examine whether laws made by Parliament or State legislatures conform to the Constitution. At the same time, the separation is not absolute: the three organs interact with one another in several areas. Parliament makes laws relating to the judiciary, the executive administers the justice system, and courts interpret laws made by Parliament. The basic principle is that one organ should not encroach upon the core constitutional function of another.

    What has been the history of parliamentary committees interacting with the Supreme Court?

    There is a precedent for parliamentary committees interacting with sitting Supreme Court Judges. In 2022, the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justice, then headed by BJP MP Sushil Kumar Modi, met then Chief Justice of India U.U. Lalit and Justice D.Y. Chandrachud. The discussions related to the e-Courts project and the functioning of the judicial system.

    The committee visited the Supreme Court again in March 2023, interacting with CJI Chandrachud and other Judges on the functioning of the National Legal Services Authority and access to free legal aid.

    These meetings show there is no general rule preventing parliamentary committees from interacting with sitting Supreme Court Judges. However, the earlier discussions were about the administration of justice and the functioning of the judiciary, not consultations with sitting Judges about the merits or constitutional validity of a Bill being examined by Parliament. That distinction is at the heart of the present controversy.

    The difficult questions

    The controversy, therefore, is not simply about whether MPs can visit the Supreme Court or meet its Judges. The more difficult question is what can appropriately be discussed in such a meeting.

    Parliamentary committees are meant to examine Bills closely and can seek views from experts and stakeholders. But the judiciary has a separate constitutional role: if a law is challenged, it has to decide whether the law meets constitutional requirements.

    The proposed visit of the panel studying ONOE has brought this boundary into focus. The committee chairman has said the proposed visit was only a study visit, while Opposition members questioned the reference to a discussion with sitting Judges on simultaneous elections. The legislature and judiciary can interact, but each must remain free to perform its own constitutional role.

    Published – October 02, 2026 11:46 am IST



    Source link

    Related Posts

    How MGR and his Tamil Nadu administration acted tough with LTTE 40 years ago
    India

    How MGR and his Tamil Nadu administration acted tough with LTTE 40 years ago

    November 19, 2026
    Maharashtra Cabinet clears university law amendments, textile policy changes and new courts in Palghar
    India

    Maharashtra Cabinet clears university law amendments, textile policy changes and new courts in Palghar

    November 19, 2026
    Israeli Parliament elects new Knesset Speaker backed by Netanyahu’s opponents
    India

    Israeli Parliament elects new Knesset Speaker backed by Netanyahu’s opponents

    November 19, 2026
    Bombay HC orders CBI, ED, IT probe into Sinhgad society; freezes bank accounts
    India

    Bombay HC orders CBI, ED, IT probe into Sinhgad society; freezes bank accounts

    November 19, 2026
    The Hindu Editorial On India’s vote against moratorium on death penalty
    India

    The Hindu Editorial On India’s vote against moratorium on death penalty

    November 19, 2026
    The Hindu Editorial On Kashmir terror attack
    India

    The Hindu Editorial On Kashmir terror attack

    November 18, 2026
    Next Post
    An agreement was signed for the supply of electricity to the border districts of Badakhshan

    An agreement was signed for the supply of electricity to the border districts of Badakhshan

    POPULAR NEWS

    2026 Regional and International Conventions of Jehovah’s Witnesses

    2026 Regional and International Conventions of Jehovah’s Witnesses

    July 7, 2026

    All posts

    July 23, 2026
    OPINION: How Argentina used war, disease, enslavement, racial ideology, immigration policies, census practices, to erase blacks

    OPINION: How Argentina used war, disease, enslavement, racial ideology, immigration policies, census practices, to erase blacks

    July 15, 2026
    This is how Nicolás Maduro and Cilia Flores reappeared in their hearing

    This is how Nicolás Maduro and Cilia Flores reappeared in their hearing

    July 24, 2026
    Thaksin, Yingluck and Paetongtarn meet Indonesian President Prabowo for investment talks

    Thaksin, Yingluck and Paetongtarn meet Indonesian President Prabowo for investment talks

    July 13, 2026

    EDITOR'S PICK

    Barbados ramps up cannabis research efforts

    Barbados ramps up cannabis research efforts

    November 6, 2026
    PM Downplays CabSec Leslie’s Link to Defense Supplier

    PM Downplays CabSec Leslie’s Link to Defense Supplier

    July 31, 2026
    Where the lights will be turned off on October 20: list of addresses from the Bishkek PES – Tazabek

    Where the lights will be turned off on October 20: list of addresses from the Bishkek PES – Tazabek

    October 23, 2026
    Michael Taylor | Before the taps run dry | In Focus

    Michael Taylor | Before the taps run dry | In Focus

    August 23, 2026

    Recent Posts

    • Midibus and minibus collided in Bağcılar, Istanbul: 18 injured
    • Riyadh’s tallest skyscraper hit in Ansar Allah strike
    • The families returning to Zabul from Pakistan have provided job opportunities for themselves
    • How MGR and his Tamil Nadu administration acted tough with LTTE 40 years ago

      © 2026 Agentially - Navigating shifting sovereignties and global risk .

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      No Result
      View All Result
      • HOME
      • AMERICAS
        • Argentina
        • Brazil
        • Canada
        • Chile
        • Colombia
        • Costa Rica
        • Cuba
        • Dominican Republic
        • Ecuador
        • El Salvador
        • Greenland
        • Guatemala
        • Honduras
        • Mexico
        • Nicaragua
        • Panama
        • Paraguay
        • Peru
        • United States
        • Uruguay
        • Venezuela
      • ASIA-PACIFIC
        • Australia
        • Brunei Darussalam
        • Cambodia
        • China
        • Federated States of Micronesia
        • Fiji
        • Indonesia
        • Japan
        • Kiribati
        • Laos
        • Malaysia
        • Marshall Islands
        • Mongolia
        • Myanmar
        • Nauru
        • New Zealand
        • North Korea
        • Palau
        • Papua New Guinea
        • Philippines
        • Samoa
        • Singapore
        • Solomon Islands
        • South Korea
        • Taiwan
        • Thailand
        • Timor-Leste
        • Tonga
        • Tuvalu
        • Vanuatu
        • Vietnam
      • CARICOM
        • CARICOM – Non-English
          • Haiti
          • Suriname
        • CARICOM Associates
          • Anguilla
          • Bermuda
          • British-Virgin-Islands
          • Cayman-Islands
          • Curacao
          • Turks-and-Caicos
        • CARICOM English
          • Antigua and Barbuda
          • Barbados
          • Belize
          • Dominica
          • Grenada
          • Guyana
          • Jamaica
          • Montserrat
          • Saint Kitts and Nevis
          • Saint Lucia
          • Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
          • The Bahamas
          • Trinidad and Tobago
      • EURASIA
        • Armenia
        • Azerbaijan
        • Balarus
        • Georgia
        • Kazakhstan
        • Kyrgyzstan
        • Moldova
        • Russia
        • Tajikistan
        • Turkmenistan
        • Ukraine
        • Uzbekistan
      • EUROPE
        • Albania
        • Andorra
        • Austria
        • Bosnia and Herzegovina
        • Bulgaria
        • Croatia
        • Cyprus
        • Czech Republic
        • Denmark
        • Estonia
        • Finland
        • France
        • Germany
        • Greece
        • Holy See
        • Hungary
        • Iceland
        • Ireland
        • Italy
        • Kosovo
        • Latvia
        • Liechtenstein
        • Lithuania
        • Luxembourg
        • Malta
        • Monaco
        • Montenegro
        • Netherlands
        • North Macedonia
        • Norway
        • Poland
        • Portugal
        • Romania
        • San Marino
        • Serbia
        • Slovakia
        • Slovenia
        • Spain
        • Sweden
        • Switzerland
        • United Kingdom
      • MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA
        • Algeria
        • Bahrain
        • Egypt
        • Iran
        • Iraq
        • Israel
        • Jordan
        • Kuwait
        • Lebanon
        • Lybia
        • Morocco
        • Oman
        • Palestinian Territories
        • Qatar
        • Saudi Arabia
        • Syria
        • Tunisia
        • Turkey
        • United Arab Emirates
        • Western Sahara
        • Yemen
      • SOUTH ASIA
        • Afghanistan
        • Bangladesh
        • Bhutan
        • India
        • Maldives
        • Nepal
        • Pakistan
        • Sri Lanka
      • SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA
        • Angola
        • Benin
        • Botswana
        • Burkina Faso
        • Burundi
        • Cabo Verde
        • Cameroon
        • Central African Republic
        • Chad
        • Comoros
        • Cote d’Ivoire
        • Democratic Republic of the Congo
        • Djibouti
        • Equatorial Guinea
        • Eritrea
        • Eswatini
        • Ethiopia
        • Gabon
        • Gambia
        • Ghana
        • Guinea
        • Guinea Bissau
        • Kenya
        • Lesotho
        • Liberia
        • Madagascar
        • Malawi
        • Mali
        • Mauritania
        • Mauritius
        • Mozambique
        • Namibia
        • Niger
        • Nigeria
        • Republic of the Congo
        • Rwanda
        • Sao Tome and Principe
        • Senegal
        • Seychelles
        • Sierra Leone
        • Somalia
        • South Africa
        • South Sudan
        • Sudan
        • Tanzania
        • Togo
        • Uganda
        • Zambia
        • Zimbabwe

      © 2026 Agentially - Navigating shifting sovereignties and global risk .

      This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.