When the pū or conch is blown, the village knows. Its call carries across water and valley, and it asks for an answer. Something is coming, so gather and prepare.
In December 1642, waka of Ngāti Tūmatakōkiri approached Abel Tasman’s ships in Mohua, Golden Bay. A challenge was sounded, perhaps on a pūtātara or pūkāea. The Dutch answered with trumpets, then fired a cannon. Both sides heard the sounds, but did either understand what the other was saying? The following day, the encounter turned violent.
Last week in Antalya, Marshall Islands President Hilda Heine sounded another warning. She told COP31 leaders that coral around her home island, alive and colourful in July, had bleached white within months. Warning of the consequences of overshooting the 1.5°C limit, Heine said the world’s response must be overwhelming, “or the world we know is over”.
In 2021, Tuvalu’s then foreign minister Simon Kofe addressed COP26 from a lectern standing in the sea. At that summit, Palau President Surangel Whipps Jr told wealthy nations that their continued emissions meant they “might as well bomb us“. Tuvalu Prime Minister Feleti Teo has called new fossil fuel projects “a death sentence for us”.
Even the UN Environment Programme’s most ambitious pathway to return global warming to 1.5°C by the end of the century anticipates a temporary peak of about 1.8°C, roughly 0.3°C above the limit. That is a pathway requiring extraordinary action, not a prediction of what current policies will deliver.
The warning has not been whispered. It has been sounded from podiums, from the sea and through the Pacific Islands Forum. If these voices have been heard for decades, is the absence of sufficient action itself an answer?
Türkiye hosts and presides over COP31, while Australia leads its negotiations. Australia has invested in renewable energy and Pacific adaptation, yet Australia’s Climate Council counts nearly 40 new, expanded or extended coal, oil and gas developments approved under the Albanese Government. Among them is the extension of Woodside’s North West Shelf gas project to 2070.
China and India sent delegations without their leaders. The United States sent no official delegation. The absence of leaders does not mean negotiations have stopped. But what message does it send to islands whose leaders have spent years asking for urgency?
Nicki Hutley, an economist and Climate Councillor with the Climate Council, likens building renewables while approving fossil fuels to filling a bath with the plug pulled out. Is that the contradiction Pacific leaders are being asked to live with?
Cultural performers at the Moana Pavilion, COP31 Antalya, Türkiye. Photo/Facebook/Fiji Government
If major emitters cannot agree on how quickly to stop the harm, can they at least agree on how quickly to help those already living with it?
Ahead of COP31, the Green Climate Fund approved about NZ3.3billion(US1.97 billion) in new climate finance at a single board meeting, covering 21 projects. It is the largest amount the fund has approved at one meeting.
Among the commitments was a grant of about NZ425million(US250 million) towards a 10-year Pacific programme covering 14 countries. With Asian Development Bank co-financing, the programme is worth about NZ1.8billion(US1.06 billion).
Tuvalu’s Coastal Adaptation Project offers both a lesson in patience and evidence of delivery. Approved in 2016, its Green Climate Fund grant of about NZ61million(US36 million) is now fully disbursed, and the UN Development Programme lists the project as completed. Completed coastal protection is not the same as another promise made at a conference.
Yet the time between approval, construction and protection matters when tides and storms do not wait. Project accounts can show money moving to agencies. Can families in Funafuti or Manihiki follow it all the way to their shoreline? Who measures whether a project changes their daily lives?
Teo has argued that Pacific countries should not have to borrow their way out of a crisis they did little to cause. With some adaptation finance supplied as loans, whose responsibility is it to ensure that help does not become another burden?
COP31 is scheduled to conclude on 20 November. There will be decisions, a communique and another round of promises to measure against delivery.
Pacific leaders already have. Heine has sounded the conch; the Cook Islands and Palau have helped shape a programme to protect their people. They are not waiting silently on the shore.
So which will reach Pacific shores first: the protection people need, or another assurance that their warning has been heard? And when the pū sounds again, will those most responsible for the storm do more than answer with yet another trumpet?














