The second version of what could be the final document of COP31, published this Thursday, no longer mentions once the fossil fuels. The call for “accelerated action to progressively eliminate fossil fuels”, which appeared in the first version, on Monday, was dropped, as well as the reaffirmation of the commitment made in Dubai, in 2023, to transition away from fossil fuels.
The new text of the Turkish presidency, which has the co-presidency of Australia, went from 18 to nine pages, and the cuts are almost always in the direction of less ambition. It is still an “unedited version”, which ministers will negotiate in the coming hours and which can only be approved by consensus. COP31 officially ends on Friday.
For Zero, the document is “disastrous”. “There is no reference to fossil fuels, nor to the need to abandon their use, and this is by far the most serious aspect”, says Francisco Ferreira, president of the environmental association. As a result of COP31, the text “would add nothing” and, in some areas, would even be “a retreat”.
For David Waskow, from the World Resources Institute (WRI), it is “encouraging” to see a shorter text that is “focused” on the issues that will be at stake until the end of the negotiations. But it points to a gap: “What we don’t see is language about transitioning away from fossil fuels in any explicit sense.”
Regarding the limit of 1.5 degrees of global warmingthe text “has been weakened”, says David Waskow, with the absence of a commitment to return to below this threshold as quickly as possible, as the UN has been advocating. Still, he considers it “absolutely essential” that this is probably the first COP to recognize that the world will exceed 1.5 degrees.
The resistance of large oil producers to any language restricting fossil fuels marked the two weeks of negotiations. In the work program on mitigation or reduction of gas emissions with greenhouse effectthe Arab Group classified any expansion of its scope as a “red line”, according to the Earth Negotiations Bulletin.
EU has not yet commented
The European Union still has no position on the new version. “We have literally just received the text,” said the Irish minister for ClimateEnergy and Environment, Darragh O’Brien, whose country presides over the EU Council. European ministers will analyze it overnight and meet again on Friday, with member states’ reactions.
The European Commissioner for Climate, Wopke Hoekstra, explained that the 27 will evaluate the text in light of three criteria: the response to the “dramatic” climate crisis and the exceeding of 1.5 degrees, the implementation and the mandate of the Member States.
Faced with the absence of any reference to fossil fuels and asked whether the EU continues to want clean electrification, Wopke Hoekstra did not elaborate. “It is very clear what the European Union’s ambition is.”
Belém outside the text
With fossil fuels, the itineraries of the Brazilian presidency of COP30, which took place in the city of Belém do Pará, for the transition to abandoning fossil fuels and stopping deforestation, which the first version welcomed.
These scripts had already been cast aside of the final Belém agreement, due to lack of consensus. The word “Belém” is no longer included in the document, and with it the follow-up to the “Belém Mission for 1.5” also comes out.
There remains an appeal for “full and expeditious” compliance with national contributions (NDC), that is, the commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions made by each country voluntarily, and adaptation plans, “informed by the results of the first global assessment” of the application of the Paris Agreementwithout any reference to what this balance said about energy.
On Saturday, the president of COP31, Murat Kurum, had already avoided promising that the theme would reach the final text. Outside the negotiations, there are countries moving forward on their own: Portugal will have a roadmap to abandon fossil fuels.
Umit Bektas/REUTERS
Electrification without being “clean”
THE goal of the Turkish presidency of increasing the share of electricity in final energy consumption to 35% by 2035 remains, “complementary” to the tripling of renewables and doubling the pace of improvement in energy efficiency. But it now appears on a list of solutions, alongside deforestation and methane. The call for a “clean electrification” it disappeared.
What gains space is the capture and storage of carbon. The text welcomes efforts to expand these technologies “urgently and quickly” and there are targets in square brackets: capturing at least 500 million tons of carbon dioxide per year by 2035 and, in one of the options, reaching 2.5 billion.
Electrification and carbon capture are the only solutions with numbers in this part of the text, a parallel that many parties “will not accept comfortably”, predicts David Waskow. The analyst criticizes the fact that carbon capture and storage and the removal of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere appear in the same paragraph: “They are not the same thing and should not be confused.”
For Greenpeace, the new version has “some deeply unacceptable elements”, starting with the carbon capture and storage target. “The Convention process (of Climate Change) has never had a goal like this”, highlights Jasper Inventor, head of the organization’s delegation at COP31. Anything that allows the fossil fuel industry to “continue polluting the climate would be a profound setback”, at a time when climate impacts are rapidly worsening.
Zero sees the references to “sustainable fuels” and carbon capture as a commitment by the Arab Group, which resists taking steps to limit the use of fossil fuels. For Francisco Ferreira, it is “clearly a false solution” to carbon dioxide emissions.
Regarding the objective of 1.5 degrees Celsius, countries reaffirm their determination to limit warming and “the magnitude and duration” of exceeding (overshoot) of this limit of the Paris Agreement. However, the decision to return below 1.5 degreesas well as the call for developed countries to achieve net-zero emissions by 2030, which now only “must lead” the efforts.
Countries are also no longer asked to review and reinforce their commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions (NDC) before the second global assessment of the Paris Agreement, scheduled for 2028, notes Francisco Ferreira. And the scientific work program on 1.5 degrees envisaged in the first version gives way to a high-level dialogue on the science of overshootat next year’s summit.
Adaptation without numbers
In financing, the value of 120 billion dollars for the tripling adaptation fundingas well as the reference base to be calculated using the Oxfam methodology. The Convention’s Standing Finance Committee will only have to prepare a report with baseline “options”. The timetable for tripling becomes something to be “discussed” in the work program on climate finance, until the next summit, which takes place in Ethiopia. What remains is the launch of an Antalya – Addis Ababa roadmap (Ethiopia hosts the 2027 COP) for financing adaptation and climate resilience.
For Jasper Inventor, from Greenpeace, the text “pushes crucial decisions to later” on how to achieve the tripling. “Developing countries and communities need predictable financing, with a clear baseline, milestones and accountability, today.”
The call for developed countries to eliminate by the end of 2027 unilateral trade measures climate-related data also disappears. The text goes on to “register concerns” about measures with cross-border impacts and repeat that climate measures should not constitute “a disguised restriction on international trade”.
The opinion of the International Court of Justice on climate change is no longer “welcomed”. The text limits itself to recognizing the leadership of small island states in asking for it.
Oceano loses ministerial dialogue
THE ocean also loses ground, with the withdrawal of high-level ministerial dialogue on ocean-climate action, as well as the invitation to countries to include ocean-related actions in transparency reports.
There is a multi-annual plan for the Dialogue on the Ocean and Climate Change, called Antalya Ocean Currentalongside a summary report, the Blue Imeceto be published by June 2028 as a contribution to the next global assessment.
The creation of a work program on mountains and climate change continues. THE just transition continues without any mention in the text.
Still, nothing is closed. In Dubai, recalls Francisco Ferreira, the second version of the text “was also dramatic”, and consensus only arrived after the official end of the summit. “There is hope, but for now it is a huge disappointment.”
PÚBLICO traveled at the invitation of the Climate Agency














