Senior Reporter
[email protected]
Relatives of Amiyr Ali fear that the investigation into his death following a boating collision two weeks ago may be impeded after a second autopsy failed to definitively determine a cause of death because his lungs are missing.
Speaking with Guardian Media, a relative who did not want to be named said she is concerned that the missing organs may contribute to the investigation being tainted, so much so that possible manslaughter charges will not be pursued.
The relative said the first autopsy was done at the Forensic Science Centre and was deemed undetermined, which she could not accept given the large gash she noticed on Ali’s face when she viewed his body.
She added that the second autopsy was done privately by Dr Hughvon Des Vignes on Thursday, and it was only then that the family learned that the organs were missing. She said although Des Vignes advised that there were traumatic injuries on her brother’s body, there is no way to say for sure if drowning was the cause of death.
“My concern is because, you know, they are already pushing a narrative stating that they didn’t have on life vests. And if it is they didn’t have on life vests and death is by drowning, well, the onus would be upon that person because they didn’t wear life vests. But if it is my brother didn’t even have a fighting chance, meaning that boat collision killed him, that is what has us where we are today.”
She added: “I personally believe, like, you know, it’s an intent to cover up manslaughter.”
Guardian Media contacted a UK-trained pathologist working in Canada, who asked not to be named. He pointed out that whenever an organ is retained, the relatives should be informed. He said the Forensic Science Centre should explain its policy on organ retention, something that created a major scandal in the UK, leading to legislative changes.
In a statement, attorney for the six families Anand Ramlogan, SC said the family wanted the Forensic Science Centre to explain why the body was released without both lungs and why Ali’s family was not informed.
He questioned whether the organs had been stored separately, misplaced, mislabelled or released with another deceased person’s remains. The family is also seeking to establish whether the lungs were deliberately withheld, concealed or destroyed.
While Ali’s relatives are battling to confirm his cause of death, his funeral has been finalised for Monday.
Probe continues
This weekend, commercial divers are expected to visit the wreckage of the crashed pleasure craft. Investigators told Guardian Media that the crash site was identified and, before the wreckage can be salvaged, divers are supposed to check the depth and condition of the wreckage.
Examining the wreckage will form part of the ongoing investigation. Investigators added that the captain of the sunken vessel is yet to give a statement. Up to yesterday, investigators continued consulting with the Director of Public Prosecutions for advice on how to proceed with the case. Earlier this week, Commissioner of Police Allister Guevarro revealed that investigators had sought an audience with the DPP.
Around 6.30 pm on November 8, the 28-foot pleasure craft BAMBALEO, travelling east near Cannings Point, collided with the 29-foot vessel BELBAGAI, which was travelling west off the coast of Chaguaramas. BELBAGAI subsequently sank, resulting in the deaths of six passengers after they were considered lost at sea.
The first body recovered was that of Anil Ahyee, which was found on November 12. Later that same day, the body of Titus Augustine was discovered. The following day, the bodies of Ali, Kieyanna Seechan and Jaheim Richards were found within hours of each other. The final victim, Lorenzo Oliver, was found on November 14.
Richards, who died from blunt force trauma, will also be buried on Monday. Augustine’s funeral is scheduled for November 26 and, the day after, Oliver will be laid to rest. Ahyee’s funeral has been scheduled for December 2. His autopsy found that he drowned.
Funeral arrangements for Seechan are yet to be finalised.















