The Superior Court has put the end point along litigation of Julieth Moncadathe young 25-year-old Colombian resident who had to leave the Encamp flat to have the pomeranian dog there Lulu After going through the Batllia and by constitutionalthe civil court considers that the ban on having animals was an “essential obligation” of the contract and endorses that the lease is terminated, therefore giving the owner the right. The sentence of November 10 also relieves him: he will not have to bear the legal costs that were claimed, of around 3,000 euros, and she will not be evicted because she already left the apartment voluntarily. “What happiness, I left very happy to know what the decision was”, she explains Moncada at diary after talking to lawyer Marc Ripoll. “Now I have peace and tranquility, I have taken a weight off of me”, he adds. About to give birth, she celebrates leaving behind a difficult bill to pay. at the same time, regrets having left home for the dog. “The situation is bitter, but I am infinitely grateful for not having to pay anything”, he says with reference to the coasts.
THE PRINCIPLE OF THE LITIGATION
The principle of litigation
It all started on November 5, 2023, when the tenant informed the owner that they had given him a puppy. The contract, signed in December 2021, it was forbidden to have pets without authorization. The landlord immediately replied that he did not allow dogs in a new home, due to the risk of damage. Moncada asked for time to look for an alternativebut the talks did not resolve the situation. Finally, the owner presented a lawsuit in February 2024 to extinguish the lease. The first resolution, of the Batlliaarrived in November 2025 and proved the tenant right: they were not listed nuisance to neighbors or damage attributable to Lulú. In March of this year, the superior reversed the result and ordered the contractual termination. Ripoll went to the Constitutional Courtwhich in July appreciated the protection appeal and annulled that decision for lack of motivation. He only demanded the superior that explained why the prohibition was determinative and why it was not necessary to prove damages.
A more motivated decision
The new ruling maintains the criterion, now more motivated. The magistrates rely on the statement of the co-tenant, who presented the veto as a decisive condition, and on the messages exchanged with the owner. According to the room, these writings show that Moncada was aware of the clause and that the lessor never tolerated the presence of the animal. The law does not generally prohibit having dogs in rental apartments, but it also does not guarantee the right to: the parties may agree on essential conditions. The Superior distinguishes this case from precedents in which an owner had tolerated pets for years. Here he understands that the veto was essential from the beginning and that, therefore, breach allows the contract to be terminated even if there is no proven damage. “It’s not the best sentence for animalists”, he admits Repollwho considers it important that the resolution specify a legal criterion after the intervention of the constitutional. The lawyer points out, however, that it is not enough to write a prohibition: it is necessary to prove that the parties accepted it as essential.
“The situation is bitter, but I am infinitely grateful for not having to pay anything”
the room does not impose costs due to the legal complexity of the case. However, this is not the same as exempting Moncada of any payment: the judgment leaves pending the liquidation of possible amounts for occupation from February 2024, deducting the rents paid, and any damages that are proven, without recovering those already discarded. the amount it will have to be fixed in execution, when the payments made are reviewed. With the lawsuit closed, his next battle is economic. He wants to recover the deposit and amounts he claims to have overpaid the owner. “Now I just have to fight to get them back, even if it’s something”, he explains. After years of uncertainty, the Juliet he wants to face the birth of the child turning the page and with less concern.
Keys
YOU WILL NOT HAVE TO PAY COURT COSTS. Julieth celebrates that she will not have to pay the costs of the trial, of around 3,000 euros. Nor will she be evicted because she had already voluntarily left the flat.
HAVE TO CHOOSE BETWEEN THE ANIMAL OR THE HOUSING. The sentence consolidates a jurisprudential criterion that allows a lease to be terminated if a prohibition on having animals, agreed as essential, is violated.















