Even with the political fissures that have recently emerged in the region, there would be pragmatic and practical value in the Caribbean Community’s (CARICOM) embrace of Mia Mottley’s apparent revisiting of a governance framework, proposed by the Ramphal Commission nearly three-and-a-half decades ago and repeated by Bruce Golding’s taskforce a quarter century later.
Ms Mottley, the Barbadian prime minister, in a speech in Kingston last week, called for a sort of executive leadership of the community. “Without a political head, CARICOM will not go any further,” Ms Mottley said. She, however, didn’t define the structure of the arrangement she has in mind.
Moreover, as the prime minister responsible for overseeing the efforts for CARICOM’s planned transition to a genuine single market and economy, and as a keen student of history, Ms Mottley is aware of the 1992 recommendations of the Shridath Ramphal-chaired West Indian Commission on ways to overcome CARICOM’s so-called implementation deficit, and their broad endorsement by Mr Golding’s group, when the island’s former prime minister was asked to review Jamaica’s relationship with CARICOM. She is also aware that a return to political federation, which has been a spectre over the region for over six decades, is off the agenda.
FORMULATE INITIATIVES
In the context of a community of sovereign nations, what the Ramphal Commission proposed in its report, Time for Action, is a three-member CARICOM Commission, one of whom would be president, with the authority to formulate initiatives for consideration by heads of government. They would possess the power, and stature, to hector governments on implementing agreements, an authority that would be strengthened by national legislation that made it explicit that decisions agreed by heads of government at CARICOM are domestic law.
The latter proposal, at this stage, would be a reinforcement of the concept of community law. In its 2013 judgment in the Shanique Myrie case, a Jamaican woman who was denied entry and abused in Barbados, the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ), sitting in its original jurisdiction as interpreter of the CARICOM treaty, held that decisions by the heads of government on hassle-free travel by CARICOM citizens were community law. The court, among other articles, invoked Article 28 of the treaty, which declares that unanimous decisions by the heads of government “shall be binding”.
LAGGED
While CARICOM has, in its more than 50 years of existence, performed more than creditably in areas of functional cooperation, it has lagged on the economic front, especially so on advancing the CARICOM Single Market and Economy (CSME), which presumes frictionless movement of goods, capital and labour within the community. Decisions taken for advancing the single market and economy are often delayed, usually to protect domestic markets. At the same time, regional governments have resisted ceding authority to a supranational implementing executive, similar to the European Union’s (EU) European Commission, to protect against perceived encroachment on national sovereignty.
But, even with its glaring shortcomings, and deepening acquiescence of some member states to external powers that weaken regional solidarity, it is a significant overstatement that Caribbean economies have found no value in regional integration. Several Jamaican firms, for example, do business relatively seamlessly across CARICOM, reversing a trend in the financial sector of the late 1990s when Trinidadian firms acquired busted Jamaican banks and insurance enterprises. And there is the fact that an estimated 10,000 Jamaicans reside in Antigua and Barbuda, which, as a ratio of its population, would be the equivalent of 300,000 Antiguans living in Jamaica. Nonetheless, there is far more to be done.
The Gleaner’s Editorial Board has long and consistently argued the value of regional conglomeration and solidarity as insulation, though limited, against the arbitrary exertion of hegemonic authority by superpowers. The board insists that CARICOM, acting as a whole, is better positioned to create insulating partnerships with countries and regions that share its values or wish to create a world order that isn’t based solely on economic wealth and/or military strength. But it recognises, too, that, at this time, some CARICOM members may be ideologically uncertain, are skittish facing hegemons, and feel that appeasement is the best route to preserving national interests.
REMAINS VALID
These stresses notwithstanding, CARICOM’s relevance as a political entity and an economic integration arrangement remains valid. CARICOM, with its arrangement for dual-track implementation of agreed initiatives, has made some headway on this front, for example with the free movement agreement between Barbados, Belize, Dominica and St Vincent and the Grenadines. However, a mechanism with the skills and political authority to both undertake triage and pursue the implementation of agreements makes sense. As the Golding taskforce recommended, any such arrangement must be underpinned by the power of sanctions.
Obvious economic breakthroughs will help drive support for CARICOM, whose integration, barriers notwithstanding, is happening informally at the level of citizens. Too little, though, is made of CARICOM’s successes. Which is another reason why Ms Mottley’s idea of a sort of political leader of CARICOM, like the president of the European Council, as a bridge between the heads of government and the technical secretariat, is logical.













