WASHINGTON – U.S. President Donald Trump has insisted that the deal he has reached with Iran is superior to the one that former U.S. President Barack Obama sealed in 2015.
Trump’s critics say at this point he has gotten much less and given up much more to Tehran.
Here is how the two agreements compare:
They are very different. The “memorandum of understanding” that Trump signed with Iran is not a final agreement but a one-and-a-half-page, 14-point framework negotiated on and off over a period of weeks.
It has launched a 60-day negotiation period to seek a full settlement of the nearly four-month war, with many hurdles yet to overcome on issues that include Iran’s nuclear program, sanctions relief and the future of the Strait of Hormuz.
Obama’s pact was a finished, detailed document titled the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) that extended to more than 160 pages. It was narrowly focused on restricting Iran’s nuclear activities, with strict benchmarks. Trump, who condemned the Obama-era deal as “horrible,” scrapped it in 2018.
Trump’s approach has been bilateral, between the U.S. and Iran. Obama brought China, France, Germany, Russia, Britain and the European Union into negotiations that lasted about two years.
Both deals involve a written commitment by Iran never to seek a nuclear weapon. Trump — who declared the nuclear threat his main reason for going to war — has insisted, incorrectly, that Tehran had never done so before.
Obama’s deal placed tight limits on Iran’s efforts to produce weapons-grade uranium, aimed at extending the “breakout” time it would need to produce a bomb. The U.S. government said Tehran had complied until Trump withdrew from the JCPOA.
Trump’s interim deal outlines only a general path toward curbing Iran’s nuclear activities, with no specific commitments from Tehran other than to discuss nuclear issues in the 60-day window.
It suggests Iran’s willingness to resolve a dispute over its near-bomb-grade uranium stockpile, including the possibility of “down blending” onsite under supervision by the International Atomic Energy Agency, the U.N. nuclear watchdog, but leaves that decision for a final deal.
The JCPOA involved extensive international inspection, but the MOU does not call for any future reinstatement of that process.
Both deals involve sanctions relief and unfreezing of assets — which Iran is now even more anxious to receive to boost its crippled economy — but in very different ways.
Obama eased some sanctions early on, but only after a comprehensive settlement was signed, and then phased in further relief based on verified steps by Iran.
Trump’s memorandum front-loads initial relief, including immediate U.S. waivers for Iran to export oil, while leaving a final package to be negotiated later.
It also opens the…
